Thursday, February 10, 2011

Ethnography Proposal


The Culture of Public Transportation

For the subject of this ethnography we intend to study the culture surrounding public transportation services. A&M in particular has an intricate culture embedded in the bus network. Unlike similar services, the one provided by A&M is free to everyone in the Bryan-College Station area, making this culture even more dynamic.
While the most obvious use of the A&M bus system is for students to transit between home and classes, the bus system is used for a large number of other activities. These other activities are the main interest of this ethnography, but the focus of the ethnography is intended to be left open ended. This is important, as it will help us to avoid biasing our methodologies To this end, we hope to make objective observations on the culture of different bus routes. Following periods of study, we will attempt to draw conclusions from the data as opposed to forming goals prior to these experiences.
In order to better study this culture, we intend to sit in on a variety of different bus routes at different times of day. Considerations worthy of mention would include bus routes that travel to significant locations (besides campus) such as North gate, the mall, or the grocery store. In addition, the culture present on some of these routes may vary significantly at different times of day. To address this, we also intend to ride the routes during various times on the weekend, and later at night.
Our group intends to collect quantitative data out of observations that are of particular interest to our ethnography. As we will describe in the qualitative data section of this proposal, our intentions are to monitor student activities that are not necessarily related to school. With that in mind, we are interesting in knowing the amount of people who ride the bus to school, and people who ride the bus to other destinations. We are interested in knowing how many commuters use their phone instead of engaging in face to face social activities. Other observations will include determining the number of grocery shoppers and the number people eating on the bus. Despite all these early ideas, it is important to mention that our research will be tailored by our commuting experience.
The qualitative data for this ethnography will involve observing the environment and describing the overall mood. This will include taking notes on how friendly the passengers are, how they are dressed, and possibly ethnic backgrounds relating different bus routes. We want to take notes on how the times (morning, noon, and afternoon) of the bus routes affect people. For example, do people only eat in the mornings? Are people more likely to engage in conversations at night? All these ideas will compose our qualitative data.

Paper Reading #7: The Coffee Lab

Comments:

Reference:
Title: The Coffee Lab: Developing a Public Usability Space
Author: Maria Karam
Venue: CHI 2010, April 10-15


Summary
The Coffee Lab is somewhat like a real coffee shop, but with several interactive systems added for usability testing. Some of these systems include the Emoti-Chair, the iGesture System, a music visualization application, and several applications relating to captions. While all of the systems undergoing testing at the Coffee Lab are projects of their own, the focus of the Coffee Lab is to explore and research the public usability lab concept. Researchers evaluated the lab in five different stages, listed here in order: exposure, experience, experiment, extension, and exploration.

Discussion
While coffee shops have a high potential for this sort of public usability testing, I personally feel that this style of usability testing is flawed in general. This idea could work with more subtle and better known technology, but I felt like some of the ideas they were trying to test would have been either sufficiently uninteresting to patrons of an ordinary coffee shop, or else sufficiently outlandish so as to discourage interaction. These factors are diminished in the article, because while the Coffee Lab aims to be set in the public domain, it is a prototype as well. The article lacks a detailed description concerning how they avoided biasing customers and patrons, which most likely means that they didn't. As a result, I feel it is likely many individuals (myself included) would approach the coffee shop as a research enviroment - this naturally piques interesting and changes behavior.

To demonstrate this, imagine we took their Emoti-Chair and set it up in a real coffee shop - one without anyone standing around giving surveys and no visible surveillance or data collection. The difference here is that the expectations of the user are different, they no longer see the chair as a prototype. As a result, the chair will not immediately stand out as special either, and users will only notice it if the chair genuinely appeals to them. In the article, the attention of users is constantly drawn the items they wish to have tested, which defeats the purpose of doing the usability test in the public domain.

Paper Reading #6: A Multi-Touch Enabled Steering Wheel

Comments:

Reference:
Title: A multi-touch enabled steering wheel: exploring the design space
Author: Max Pfeiffer and 5 others
Venue: CHI 2010, April 12-13



Summary
The article details the author's design for a multi-touch steering wheel. This means that the steering wheel is intended to serve multiple functions, namely allow the user to interact with the car radio or computer system without taking their hands off of the steering wheel. A camera was used for the multi-touch tracking, while a projector mounted in the steering wheel column was used to display an interface onto the acrylic glass surface of the prototype steering wheel.

Discussion
I liked the idea behind this article. Unlike most of the other articles I have read, I feel like this project has real application, and related directly to CHI. While the prototype used in this article does of course have serious shortcomings, such as structural integrity, these are things that would be quickly sorted out by manufacturers if the design ever made it into industry. To some degree however, making the steering wheel purely electronic would be a mistake, as this vastly increases the number of points of failure for the system. The proposed system would need to undergo an absolutely huge amount of testing.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Week #1: Ethnography Results

Week #1: Ethnography Results

Due to some confusion about how groups would be assigned, my group formed this morning. We decided to go with my second idea regarding an ethnography of the A&M public transportation system and the culture surrounding it. Currently our team has only two members, myself and Angel Narvaez.

Monday, February 7, 2011

Book Reading #13: Microblog for Opening Skinner's Box

Chapter 3
Summary
This chapter relates the experiences of Dr. Rosenhan while running an experiment to fake a mental illness in order to be admitted to a psychiatric ward. The author then repeated this experiment her self, and relates her own experiences. In contrast to Dr. Rosenhan's results, Slater was unable to convince psychiatrists that she should be admitted to a ward, however she was prescribed several medications, including anti-psychosis drugs.

Discussion
While this chapter was interesting, I can't help but feeling like Dr. Rosenhan's experiment was just some sort of silly bet with some friends. Following some google research, it appears that there are also some doubts that Slater actually preformed the experiment that she has never addressed. This also brought up some other points regarding the accuracy of previous chapters in the book (especially the first). All things considered, I am much less impressed with the author following this chapter.

Book Reading #12: Microblog for Coming of Age in Samoa

Chapter 4
Summary
The focus of this chapter was on the samoan family hierarchy. Hierarchy is mostly determined by age as opposed to sex, although the matai, who is head of the household, is typically male. Additionally, the matai is sort of outside the age-based hierarchy.

Discussion
Probably the most interesting aspect of samoan hierarchy is that status is largely independent of sex. This is not completely true, as the majority of matai's are men, and women, even as children, are typically expected to raise children and so forth. However, in contrast to most of the other well known cultures, samoa is remarkably close to equality between the sexes.

Book Reading #11: Microblog for The Design of Everyday Things

Chapter 4
Summary
This chapter focuses on the constraints commonly faced by designers. These include physical, cultural, and semantic constraints. The author uses the example of a lego motorcycle to demonstrate these concepts by pointing out that while the components of the motorcycle are largely interchangeable, the cultural and semantic constraints would not be met and most people would no longer recognize the toy as a motorcycle. A discussion of logical constraints is then included later. Norman then returns to the more specific topic of door design touched on in earlier chapters, and closes the chapter with some insights on how to improve light switches so that they are less ambiguous.

Discussion
Norman has some excellent points in this chapter, although I feel in general most doors are apparent in their use. The cases where poor design was used however do stand out in my mind. Light switches are a slightly different manner. Having unlabeled switches is generally alright, provided that there aren't a great number of lights in the vicinity of the switch. I can think of maybe one or two instances in my own apartment where the switches could be labeled, but in general it is not necessary as most people learn very quickly. Switches in public places however could stand to benefit greatly from improved design, and would probably be more worth the investment.